Tuesday, October 19, 2010

august 18, 2007

[some years ago, after reading "between noon and three: Romance, Law, and the Outrage of Grace" by robert capon] now, the middle ground is what im looking for.

.............

What if we somehow found out that everything we’ve believed & regarded as truth, was not truth, but, in fact, lies that we’ve created & labeled as truth?
What if the beliefs we hold & value that make up our ‘faith’ are only based on how we experience reality?

What if we’re wrong about all of this?


Our experiences determine how we interpret the world around us, & thus, create our worldview.
So people with different experiences are inevitably going to possess different worldviews.
A person of privilege is going to experience the world in a much different way than a person without privilege, leading to very different worldviews, which again, are formed by different experiences of reality.
Where does one person or group’s worldview become ‘more true’ than another person’s worldview?
‘It is always someone’s or some group’s construction of reality that ends of being the dominant construction that guides social life.’
Unfortunately, people of privilege (us) have constructed reality in a way that benefits them (us), & only them (us), with no concern for those without privilege (them).


‘Why is it YOUR construction of reality, YOUR collective hunch, that rules?’

If all of reality has been constructed by dominant privileged groups in society, & I am unquestionably a part of the privileged group & therefore have only experienced reality as a member of the privileged group & not as one without privilege, I am forced to reflect on the influence this has had on my faith, values, & beliefs.
I have no choice but to question the core of my beliefs & how they have been culturally conditioned to fit the dominant view of reality.


If I was a person without privilege, how would reality have shaped my beliefs differently?
How would my experiences have changed what I claim to be truth in my privileged position?

There is an intimate relationship between my privilege & the way I experience reality, truth, & faith.
I need to not ignore that, but willingly embrace it, & seek to explore it, despite the disturbing realizations I might come to as a result.

I believe we have created truth to be what we want it to be and if real truth exists we will not find it because it is impossible to separate ourselves from a reality in which we know nothing else.
Although faith is required from us as Christians, we must at least open ourselves up to the reality that we might be wrong. Too much certainty, in my opinion, is one of the biggest downfalls in the American churches today.

As much as many of us like to pretend, we really have no idea who God is.
We don’t know if He exists. We’re scared to say that, but we have no tangible proof. For many of us, we probably believe in God because either
1) we were raised that way
2) the Bible
3) our own experience
all of which are faith-based.
When I believe in something based solely on faith, (faith in the beliefs of those who raised me, faith that the Bible is God’s Word, & in a way ‘more true’ than any other book written, & faith that in my own experiences, whatever I experienced, really was God) I have to leave room for the possibility that I might be wrong.

‘How is it possible to judge the worldview of another person or group of people to be wrong when we realize that we have no privileged, universal access to truth & so can only pass judgment from the perspective of our own worldview?’

‘How can we presume that our own worldview is so in touch with reality (to say nothing about being in touch with God!) that we can magisterially pronounce on the truth or falsity of any other worldview?’

Opening myself up to that possibility does not mean my faith is weak or wrong & it doesn’t mean the things I believe aren’t true. I hold certain beliefs, as we all do, which I believe to be true. Obviously. Or else I wouldn’t ‘believe’ them. But what we’ve often been taught is that a solid faith, one strong enough to move mountains, is a faith 100% certain that what it believes is right. But that kind of faith is a faith refusing to ever be wrong. It is a faith that rejects any new experiences that might prove long-held beliefs wrong. It is a faith more concerned with ‘rightness’ than ‘realness.’


I carve my beliefs on stone, comfortable with the ignorant permanence of the engravings.


When I allow myself to contemplate the idea that I might be wrong, the nature of my faith changes.

It becomes more honest & less ignorant. It becomes more vulnerable & less secure. It acknowledges my limited & narrow experience in this world as a person of privilege, instead of believing everyone experiences life the way I do. It painfully realizes my own unawareness, instead of denying it.
It’s open for change, instead of set in its ways.

I need to change the way I think about my beliefs, carry my beliefs, share my beliefs, listen to the beliefs of others, & live my beliefs.

I have been taught to think about my beliefs in terms of black & white, with no room for gray.
I have been taught to carry my beliefs with an attitude of arrogance, instead of an attitude of humbleness.
I have been taught to share my beliefs in a manner that claims to know absolute truth, possess all the answers, & understand the way in which one becomes ‘saved.’
I have been taught to listen to others’ beliefs with an open ear, but only while keeping a closed heart.
I have been taught to live my beliefs in a way that passively accepts surface answers, refuses to question traditional thinking, & is primarily concerned with my own morality.

I write my beliefs in the sand, accepting the crashing waves that wash away the words, recreate the sentences & refresh the meanings of existing ideas.


By looking at the world around me, my own ignorance is revealed. The experiences of others tell me faith is not what we have made it to be here in America. I become faced with a choice to either remain comfortable in my ignorance & content with what I have been taught to believe up to this point, or I can admit my ignorance & seek to reconcile my beliefs with the experiences of those who are different than me, with the risk of being criticized, judged, or in the worst cases, persecuted.

By choosing the latter, life becomes a lot more complicated & confusing. Suddenly, I feel no more security & protection. The once reassurance that god, assuming there is a god, has been happy with me & the way I have chosen to live my life is gone. When the truths I have become so reliant upon to save me are out of the picture, feelings of fear & terror overwhelm my soul. I feel lost, with no direction, & a sense of betrayal & abandonment from those who have led me astray.

…but I also feel free….
Free to love unconditionally.
Free to think creatively.
Free to doubt & be uncertain.
Free to share experiences with those who are different in a way that challenges & changes my faith.

I feel free to walk in a beautiful, unfamiliar land, discovering what the outsiders have insisted is not worth discovering, yet I have found otherwise.



Think about what you believe.
Think about why you believe it.
Think about how your upbringing has affected what you believe.
Think about how culture has influenced what you believe.
Think about your privilege & the impact that has on what you believe.
Think about how your beliefs are affecting those around you without privilege, whether negatively or positively.
Think about why being ‘right’ is so important to us.
Think about why we feel like we have to have answers for people.
Think about why we are not open to change.


think. question. change.

No comments:

Post a Comment